Home    Subscribe    Contact    Login

What do You Think of Giving Time Out?

by helenonthesofa (follow)
Check out my Weekend Notes articles here: www.weekendnotes.com/profile/160877
Question (18)      Discipline (6)      Punishment (1)      Time Out (1)     
Before having children, I'd caught many an episode of the UK's Super Nanny and made mental notes of the effective use of reward charts and the 'time out' or naughty step that seemed to be a great non violent discipline method. Since having kids, and having put certain strategies into play, I still marvel at the effectiveness of the reward chart, of positive reinforcements and when needed, how a time out can be great to discipline and to calm down a particularly fraught child.




Lately, I've noticed an increase in the number of articles disagreeing with the use of 'time outs' for a myriad of reasons including children feeling abandoned, humiliated and over time having a decreased self esteem. As with many parenting topics, there are pros and cons with however you choose to parent, and I tend to go with what works for the personalities of my children, and my own style.

Do you give time outs to your children (or have you), and do you see any harm from this method?

Related Articles

1. Reward Charts
2. Calming Down as a Parent

#Question
#Discipline
#Punishment
#Time Out
I like this Question - 6
[ Submit an Answer ]
Top Answers
I think time outs are a great form of discipline and I don't agree with those who criticise it. The whole point is that the child should feel left out because they have done wrong, and that is the punishment. If they behave then they don't get left out of things. How are you meant to discipline a child if there aren't consequences to bad behaviour?
I don't like time out at all. I have never used it with my son and I chose his pre-school on the basis that they also don't use time out but time in.
I think it's important to teach a child that even when you don't like their behaviour you still love them and are there for them. So when something happens that is less than ideal (!) we cuddle and talk about it. If he is too angry or upset for that, then I will just hold him until he has calmed down, usually with some skin contact if I can, then we will talk about it.
I want my son to grow up with the ability to work out the best way to behave in a situation for himself and not just to do the right thing because he's scared he will be punished if he behaves otherwise.
Discipline means to teach, not to punish!
Thanks for sharing this alternative means of managing behavior. Really interesting.
I think you have to parent the best you can knowing your own child and what works for them. There's pros and cons with everything and if you see your child suffering severe affects from different methods you try then obviously you adjust them to suit.
I always preferred to see it as quiet time. Children misbehave for all sorts of reasons, and we know ourselves that when we get angry, aggressive or argumentative, the best way to get out of it is to remove ourselves from the situation for a while to calm down. Quiet time - or time alone - should be a positive experience, not a punishment as such. Instead of being made to sit in a corner and stew, this time can be used for calming activities like reading, colouring-in or writing a 'sorry' note. This time to reflect is much more valuable and more effective for helping a child channel their emotions positively. It worked best for my 3 children, and they turned out fine! :)
I know I definitely appreciate my own calm down time. I've recently observed that my eldest benefits from some calm time reading a book. The change in temperament can be very obvious!

I don't like the concept. We do time in instead. It's a much gentler alternative and it doesn't involve withholding affection.
That sounds a nice alternative, what would that involve? Thanks
You can read about it here if you'd like :-)

http://joanneaz_2.tripod.com/positivedisciplineresourcecenter/id26.html
by meggf
Here
by meggf
Share: email  facebook  twitter
More Articles by helenonthesofa
A wonder week is a parenting term that no one really talks about prior to babies coming along, and s...
396 views
This cheerful little game is aimed at pre schoolers aged 3 and overs and is very easy to get the h...
98 views
When you are breastfeeding, there may be times when you might still need to give your baby a bottle...
196 views
**Do you want to know what BF, DD1 or BLW mean?** When I was pregnant with my first child, I star...
191 views
Cloth nappies have evolved considerably in the last 10 years and the days of your choice being limit...
285 views
For toddlers, there are many ways for learning to occur, and for many it will not happen in a struct...
163 views
view all articles by helenonthesofa
Articles by helenonthesofa on Other Hubs
When I was a teenager and my mum wouldn't let me dye my dirty blonde hair to make it lighter, I'd re...
9 likes
My Google Plus Profile
ID: 27610
Trending Articles
If you're looking for cheap baby goods for your baby, here are some excellent stores you can go to t...
9921 views
When the clocks change, or in summer months, it can be difficult if your baby wakes extra early ...
4056 views
One way of cutting the cost of having a baby is to get some of your baby items second hand
8186 views
Most preschoolers love telling jokes but don't always 'get' the punch line or might instead tell...
by Jane
2013 views
IPads are a great way to keep kids busy on long journeys or while waiting for appointments
by Jane
1531 views
Going camping with a baby can be a daunting prospect
by Jane
1879 views
I love crystals and have a few in my collection, so when junior got a Crystal Growing Kit for Christ...
1695 views
My 10 year old daughter has a friend who Iím pretty sure is headed down the road of self-destructi...
184 views
As the school holidays in Australia reach over the halfway point and the new school year beckons, pa...
183 views
If your little one has bad nappy rash, they probably feel totally miserable
4 answers
Categories
Parenting (156)
Play (88)
Tips (47)
Eating (32)
Travel (27)
Safety (23)
Sleep (11)
 
Copyright 2012-2018 OatLabs ABN 18113479226. mobile version